Are Chelsea the worse CL finalists ever? And why do CL winners go downhill after their success?
I love the Champions league. It is compulsive viewing, involves the best players in the world and produces some marvellous sporting theatre and some interesting attack versus defence training sessions too. However call me a nostalgic stig in the dump but seasons like this one with Chelsea in the final, I find it hard to stand tall and say we are watching Europe’s finest, even if they are there by merit, which they are. In 2005 Liverpool’s champions league winning side contained Steve Finnan,Djimi Traore, Vladimir Smicer and Milan Baros. Many people (mainly English) football fans argue that this is one of the worst teams/squads to win the champions league. A starting XI of:
Dudek, Finnan, Carragher, Hypia, Traore, Alonso, Garcia, Gerrard, Kewell, Baros and Riise doesn’t scream ‘best team in Europe’ but when you look at the strength in depth; a bench of Carson, Josemi, Hamann, Nunez, Biscan(!!) Cisse and Smicer it begs the question how on earth did they prevail at all in a competition so tough for such a long period.
It has been put to me that this years Chelsea line up could rival Liverpool’s 2005 effort with the likes of Bosingwa, Romeu, Kalou, Mikel and Malouda and whilst I agree this is not a strong Chelsea line up and these players are substandard it is slightly over-crictical on players who only a few seasons ago were winning the double for Chelsea under Ancelotti. Biscan and Traore never came close to this level before their CL victory.
Clearly the campaign in 2005 took its toll on Liverpool who finished the season in 5th on 58 points (the same as Bolton Wanderers) a whopping 37 points (enough to survive relegation) behind the league champions Chelsea. So my question is, with Chelsea struggling this season, finishing in 6th; does the Champions League have a detrimental effect on league form? Furthermore I am keen to examine how the standard of the CL has fluctuated and conclude what impact success (in this case judged by making the final) in the CL has on future club league campaigns.
Summary of Results:
1) Since 1993 there have been 19 finals (38 teams).
2) 23/38 the number of finalists who win their league the year before reaching the final.
3) 20/38 the number of finalists who win their league the same year as reaching the final.
4) 13/38 the number of finalists who win their league the year after reaching the final.
5) 8 – the number of finalists who don’t even finish in the top 3 the next year.
The first point to pick up on is the contention that teams success in the CL is a hindrance to their league form. The statistics show a more logical contrary that good league form generally has a positive effect on CL progress. This makes sense, as it is clear that by and large the strongest team in a particular league that season are more likely to progress in the CL. It is also pertinent to note that although the number is over half it could be argued that just over 50% of CL finalists winning their domestic league is a relatively low figure given their superiority in Europe’s premier club competition.
The standard itself clearly fluctuates every year with peaks of goliath clashes between all conquering sides like Barca and Man United in 2009 or Ajax and AC Milan in 1995 to a final in 2007 where neither runners up Liverpool nor AC Milan finished higher than 3rd in the season before, during or after the CL final – How can this be a champions league when 2 underachieving domestic sides battle out Europes flagship club tournament?
23 of the 48 finalists won their league prior to reaching the final illustrating that the most important ingredient to being a finalist is league success. This figure is slightly distorted by the fact that only league champions were initially allowed in the competition but since 2000 (when top European leagues were allowed 4 competitiors) there have been 12 finals and 8 have been won by champions of their league the year before so it is a strong trend.
The most interesting statistic however and probably the most relevant argument of this article is that success in the CL seriously hampers your progress the following domestic season. Whether it is burnout or over inflated expectations teams just simply can’t back up their CL success with league form. Possibly putting credence to the argument that it should be called a Champions Cup not League as clearly the facets of a winning team aren’t consistency or ‘winning when your not playing well’ but being able to take an opponent down over two legs through whatever methods, tactics or bus parking you require. Only 13 clubs followed up a CL final appearance with league success the following year. This very low considering the calibre of teams we are talking about coupled with the stat that 23 finalists are present in the final off the back of winning a league yet don’t seem to be able once they reach the pinnacle of European club football keep the run going. Huge teams such as this years Barca and Man United teams who played in the final last year have finished 2nd in their respective leagues further franking the trend. Ajax 96 , Porto 04 Barca 06 Inter 11 are all examples of all conquering domestic sides who failed to follow up several years of domestic dominance once they won the CL final. Could it be that these successful teams take their foot off the gas once they have ‘achieved it all’? I’m not so sure about that but their must be something deep set has caused this consistent spate of underachievement after major achievement. I suppose the phrase ‘after the lord mayors show’ was invented for examples like this and it seems unequivocal that there is a correlation between CL success and subsequent below par domestic league form.
Whilst I accept that there are a large number of variables involved in CL and league success; injuries, suspensions, transfer windows, cup runs, managerial changes (in Chelsea’s case they seem to succeed once they have one…Hiddink, Grant, Di Matteo) it doesn’t dilute the fact that despite having the ability to attract big names, gain more money through sponsorship and TV rights the bottom line is it doesn’t bring consistency and despite good cup teams like Chelsea, Liverpool, Arsenal, Valencia, Bayer Leverkusen and arguably AC Milan being successful none have been able to build a lasting dynasty of success akin to that of Man United, Barcelona or Bayern Munich and that is precisely the reason why I loved the old format. Yes it was exclusive, possibly over elitist and not always the best spectacle, as the champions of Finland provided a test in line with a championship side when we could be watching Real Madrid, Spain’s second best team in action. To me however it was just what it said on the tin…
…The Champions League; Smicer, Traore and Biscan need not apply.
SL
Appendix
The first value represents the league finishing position the season before reaching the final. The second indicates their league position the season they reached the final and the third number shows their finishing position the season after the CL final. A dash or hyphen indicates the team finished outside the top 3 that season.
Winners Runner-up
2011 Barca 1st 1st 2nd MU 1st 1st 2nd
2010 Inter 1st 1st 2nd BM 2nd 1st 3rd
2009 Barca 1st 1st 1st MU 1st 1st 2nd
2008 MU 1st 1st 1st CH 2nd 2nd 3rd
2007 AC 3rd – - LIV 3rd 3rd -
2006 Barca 1st 1st 2nd ARS 2nd – -
2005 LIV - - 3rd AC 1st 2nd 3rd
2004 PORT 1st 1st 2nd Monaco 2nd 3rd 3rd
2003 JUVE 1st 1st 3rd AC - 3rd 1st
2002 RM 1st 3rd 1st BL – 2nd –
2001 VAL 3rd – 1st BM 1st 1st 3rd
2000 RM 2nd - 1st VAL – 4th 3rd
1999 MU 2nd 1st 1st BM 2nd 1st 1st
1998 RM 1st – 2nd JUVE 1st 1st –
1997 BD 1st 3rd – JUVE 2nd 1st 1st
1996 AJAX 1st 1st - JUVE 1st 2nd 1st
1995 AJAX 1st 1st 1st AC 1st – 1st
1994 AC 1st 1st - BARCA 1st 1st -
1993 Mars 1st – 2nd AC 1st 1st 1st
Time to ‘Mull’ over the new Flat season before the “Battle of Chiswick” on Sunday
The 2012 turf flat season is finally here and it is an exciting time for racing fans. With the Grand National still on the horizon and the prep races for the early season classics around the corner we have an exciting overlap of jumping and flat racing to look forward to.
The traditional curtain raiser, the Lincoln, run at Doncaster is always a tricky conundrum with the draw as well as a lack of form making punting particularly tricky. Eton Forever who won the spring mile at this meeting last year is a worthy favourite for this blogs favourite flat trainer Roger Varian. Varian produced several winners for us last season however 6-1 seems a low in such a competitive race and despite shorter priced horses having a good record in the recent years 6 of the last 9 winners have been 10-1 or less I think there is more value to be found. Usually the money speaks wonders early season and Penitent the 2010 winner is a classic illustration opening at double figures and cruising home to score by 2 lengths at 3/1 fav. The horse which finished 3rd that year Mull of Killough is however my idea of a likely winner. Back in he winners enclosure already this year over a mile on the all weather and with course and distance form and VC bet still offering 16-1 I think that is a decent bet. There has been a fair bit of money around for this horse and I suspect it may shorten up again in the morning. It is also worth keeping an eye on the market becuase it often speaks volumes in these early season races. Read More…
Champions League and FA Cup due to be upstaged by some mid-week, lower league footy
Derby v Blackpool
There’s been a big move on Blackpool this afternoon after opening up at 8/5 they are now a bet price of 11/8.
- Both teams have scored in all 9 of Blackpool’s last 9 games (home and away) so the over 2.5 goals in an attractive bet. I prefer this to both teams to score as
- Derby failed to score against Leicester and Reading in their last two run outs at home.
- Blackpool have won their last three away games 3-1
- 11 of last 12 Blackpool away games have had O2.5 goals
3 points over 2.5 goals – 10/11 coral
1 point Blackpool 3-1 – 22/1 ladbrokes
Carlisle v Rochdale
Carlisle have an excellent home record, where as Rochdale are very weak away from home, 8th v 23rd in the table.
- Carlisle haven’t lost at home since 10th September, 12 games unbeaten at home
- Rochdale’s last victory away from Spotland came 9 games ago, a 1-0 win over Preston
- In the last 8 away games, Rochdale have scored one goal, with one 1-1 and three 0-0.
3 points Carlisle -0.25 on Asian Handicap at 1.78 with 188bet
MK Dons v Yeovil
- MK Dons home games average 3.1 goals whilst Yeovil away games average 2.8 goals
- The 8 home and away games for Yeovil have seen both teams score
- Yeovil have scored 8 goals in their last 4 away games
- MK Dons scored 9 goals in their last 4 home games
2 points Both teams to score – 5/6 coral
Swindon v Dag and Red
Swindon have an amazing home record winning their last 8 home games. Swindon’s away record is poor, only one away win in their last 14 away games. Rather than back Swindon at 2/5 there is some value on the correct score market.
- Four of Swindon’s last 8 home wins have finished 2-0
1 point Swindon 2-0 – 11/2 with Coral
CM
After a huge 250-1 football treble last weekend, we delve deep into football betting’s latest adage “if both teams score it’s goals galore!”
After a 250/1 treble on the football last week, I’m taking a look at the both teams to score market this weekend.
The Theory
When making selections on this market I tend to look for four main factors.
- Home team – how many times have both teams scored in the last 6 home games for the home?
- Away team – how many times have both teams score in the last 6 games for the away team?
- Home matches Over 2.5 goals – How many games have featured over 2.5 goals for the last 6 games involving the home team at home?
- Away matches over 2.5 goals – How many games have featured over 2.5 goals for the last 6 games involving the away team on their travels?
The beauty of this system is that simplesoccerstats.com provides all the work for you using their mini console.
In order for a selection to be made, A must equal at least 4 out of 6, B must equal 4 out of 6. Obviously if a team is 5 out of 6, or even 6 out of 6 then this will make a stronger selection. C and D are also important selections and I look for at least 3 out of 6 on both of these, with preferably the pair combining to at least 7.
Example
So taking the early kick off in league one between Oxford and Swindon. A big local derby, let’s take a look at the game through the mini console.
- Both teams have scored 5 times in the last 6 Oxford home games. Oxford have only failed to score at home on one occasion, a 1-0 loss to Crewe.
- Swindon have also been involved in games where both teams have scored 5 of their last 6 away games. They have won ten games on the bounce and scored 2 or more in their last four away games.
- 3 of the 6 Oxford home games have had 3 goals or more with two 1-1 draws.
- 4 of the 6 Swindon away games have had 3 goals or more, including the last 4.
A final factor to consider is other news. Positions in the league, team news and obviously price are important. Generally the best selections are when the away team is a slight favourite.
Di Canio has this to say on the match…. ‘”It’s a special game to play for the players, for the manager but especially for the fans. I don’t want to put more pressure on my players because if they do the job they have been doing we are going to win again. We want to make it a special day for our fans. I think they are very happy at the moment for what we have done until now, but we want more for us. We are going to play our positive, attacking football because we want to win and get the extra satisfaction from this game.”
All this points to a game where both teams are expected to, with the match fulfilling the four criteria for a selection.
I’d summarise the game as follows.
| Match | Home BTS | Away BTS | Home o2.5 | Away o2.5 | Total | Best Price |
| Oxford v Swindon |
5 |
5 |
3 |
4 |
17 |
5/6 |
* bts = both teams to score
So using these criteria, I’ve laid out potential selections for this weekend. Sometimes quite a few games qualify for selection, at other times the selections are minimal.
| Match | Home BTS | Away BTS | Home o2.5 | Away o2.5 | Total | Best Price |
| Oxford v Swindon |
5 |
5 |
3 |
4 |
17 |
5/6 |
| Blackburn v Villa |
5 |
4 |
5 |
4 |
18 |
4/6 |
| Fulham v Wolves |
4 |
6 |
4 |
3 |
17 |
5/6 |
| Barnsley v Forest |
5 |
4 |
5 |
4 |
18 |
4/5 |
| Cardiff v West Ham |
5 |
4 |
5 |
4 |
18 |
4/5 |
| Bury v Huddersfield |
5 |
4 |
4 |
4 |
17 |
8/11 |
| Gateshead v Ebbsfleet |
5 |
6 |
3 |
5 |
19 |
7/10 |
| Southport v Newport |
4 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
19 |
7/10 |
| York v Hayes |
5 |
4 |
6 |
5 |
20 |
10/11 |
| Granada v Valencia |
5 |
5 |
5 |
4 |
19 |
4/5 |
Bets – Both teams to score
1 point on Oxford, Barnsley, Cardiff, Blackburn @ 17/2 with Blue Square
1 point on Blackburn, Fulham, Bury, Granada @ 8/1 with Coral
1 point on York, Bury, Cardiff, Oxford @ 19/2 with bet365
0.1 point Oxford, Blackburn, Fulham Barnsley, Cardiff, Bury, Gateshead, Southport, York, Granada @ 250/1 General.
Good luck!
CM
White Van Man bringing home a lorry full of loot: SL reflects on all pre season betting advice
With 14 games left it seems a good time to see whether or not our pre season bets are going to come home to roost.
Advice :
5 pts win – Man United to win the Prem @ 13/8 (General) Curently trading - 15/8
This bet looks ok (ish), United will be buoyed by their recent comeback at Stamford Bridge and it appears City aren’t as infallable as they had looked before Christmas. I am still happy that United, with course and distance are more likely to prevail.
1pt Blackburn to be relegated @ 10/3 (coral)
They are now as short as 1/3 with some bookies (best priced 8/15) and despite creating chances they can’t seem to pick up points. Their drubbing at the weekend won’t do their confidence any good and with no other teams emerging as real no hopers (we will come to Wigan in a minute) I am pleased to be on them 6 points better off than their current market position. They could be subject to a bit of laying if you had a pretty big bet. I still think they will probably drop and if their form miraculously revives they will never get bigger than the original 10/3 all season so laying is always a possibility.
3 pts Wigan to be relegated @ 2/1 (coral)
Best priced at 2/9 we are on a real winner with Wigan. They can’t put the ball in the net, are struggling to pick up points and will almost certainly be relegated. 2/1 now looks like a great price.
I was also pleased to avoid the promoted sides. QPR are struggling however are still around 2/1 from odds on at the start and Norwich and Swansea – who both have been very impressive are 28/1!
3 pt win Robin Van Persie to be Top Goalscorer @ 9/1 (betfair)
RVP is now 4/11 to scoop the Golden Boot and the bookies are almost paying out. 21 league goals already and at nearly a double figure price it looks as if our man will win this at a canter. He has been fit all season and has almost single handedly kept Arsenal fighting – Robin I tip my cap to you.
1 pt e/w Jermain Defoe to be Top Goalscorer @ 40/1 (sporting bet & Paddy Power) – Not played enough games. Still in the top 15 but won’t challenge the White Van Man for boots coated in Gold.
Original Article:
With the recent riots about as welcome as Rudi Voeller in a Dutch dressing room , the premiership season gets underway this weekend with some of the worlds greatest players returning to action along with a whole host of average ones.
In previewing a season the hardest thing to gauge is how strong the promoted clubs are. Blackpool last year, dead certs for relegation drubbed Wigan on the opening day. their season was turbulent and they did end up dropping. This illustrates the value of punting early as a topsy turvy season can cause prices to shift quite dramatically. I am going to ignore the promoted clubs as they are all odds on and can back them at that price are seeing how poor they really are (or are not). I think Swansea will struggle but I think the two that might go with them may already be established in the prem. Blackburn are my first pick. Their form in 2011 was worse than all those clubs relegated. This sort of form would send any manager to the slaughter house and I expect Blackburns owners to have wrung Steve Keen’s neck by christmas leaving the Scotsman to run around heedlessly before returning to being a number 2 somewhere. Keen is favourite to be sacked first, yet Blackburn with Coral are 10/3 to be relegated. I think this is a good price – especially as their squad is getting thinner by the day and they may lose Samba (which I suspect they won’t now).
Roberto Martinez is a good, loyal manager who tries to play attacking , attractive football. Sadly at Wigan he has a side that are capable of neither. Rodallega, Cleverly and N’zogbia starred for the Latics last season and with only 1 of that triumvirate left, 2/1 (coral) also looks a good bet for them to slip into the cauldron of Championship next season. The promoted clubs often come up with hunger and desire for the challenge that is slowly ebbed away by tired legs and weary dilapidated squads. Lots of promoted teams have a competitive enough first 11 but usually lack strength in depth and once a few injuries take their toll they struggle. I think a few of the sides coming up may start brighter than teams like Wigan and Blackburn and therefore think it is worth condemning the Lancashire clubs to their Championship doom with their parachute on their back.
The top of the league looks more competitive than ever and with Man City buying the world, Liverpool strengthening and Arsenal signing more Theo Walcott’s, the league looks strong. Add to that mix, 6 strikers Chelsea who spent buckets in January on Shevchenko – MARK 2 and 5 strikers Tottenham, I am looking forward to some epic super Sundays. I normally rant at this point of the year at how Man United look weaker than ever and that I don’t rate their team and they usually go on to win the league. This year is quite the opposite. Their defence looks excellent and with Smalling and Jones as back up there is strength in depth. Their midfield is strong too and Ashley Young is set for a career defining season which I feel will help establish himself as an England regular. If they add Sneijder too their side is frightening and I feel Fergie is competing against Barca now and not the rest of the prem. 13/8 is their best price and I think they are a shoo-in.
The Golden Boot is also something I like to dabble in. In truth it isn’t that easy. Injury often rules out players chances. The top clubs rotate, so would Darren Bent be a good shout as he will probably play every game? Not at 11/1. I must admit to having backed Robin Van Persie at 12/1 a few weeks ago he is about 8/1 now which is a touch short but if (it’s a big if) he stays fit then he will play most games and will rack up the goals. Stuart Downing whipped in more crosses than anyone else last year, a repeat would see Andy Carroll in contention (20/1) however that price is because of his injury prone nature and I will stay clear of him. Of more interest is Jermain Defoe. Proven goalscorer, playing for a top 6 team, he is best priced 45/1 (betfair) or 40/1 (with an e/w market – Paddy Power). At longer prices Peter Odemwingie is 100/1 , if he produces the form of last year he may be up there and he takes penalties. His namesake Peter Crouch may move to Stoke and a regular berth there with some direct football could make his 100/1 look a big price too.
The best of the rest contains as per usual the top four’s cast offs. Steve Bruce has finally achieved his goal of establishing Sunderland as Man United B – cue return of Wellbeck on loan. Stoke aren’t happy with Fuller and Jones’ aerial prowess so are trying to add well needed inches in the box with Crouch or Bendtner to nod in crosses and throws. If they get Crouch they will be a decent side based on their FA cup run last year if, they get Bendter expect their relegation price to shorten – The potters would probably rather have Delilah up top. Villa, Everton and Bolton are likely to scrap hard and achieve nothing and if the latter don’t add to their squad they may be light on goals minus Sturridge.
It is intriguing these riots started shortly after Joey Barton started training on his own, read into that what you will but Newcastle have a season of over expectation and pointless optimism to overcome before they finally sack Pardew and Mike Ashley decides he could do the job better probably with a couple of mates who have won the lot on Championship Manager. Why not go the whole hog and put a pair of football boots on and slip into the number 9 shirt. Make Shearer proud. Talking of Championship Manager, is there any mileage in a new game Football owner? It seems like British football is a honey pot for these new owners – just ask Bryan Robson, he could get you in at a few clubs providing you buy him enough beers in the United club bar.
The total of foreign owners is detailed below and it is an increasing worry that the game slips out of the hardy roots it once thrived in and is as everyone continues to re-iterate a ‘business’ which we must ‘recognise in order to move with the times’ – Disappointing. Business style ownership can lead to financial security but in the most part causes corruption and a distancing from the reality of being a football fan…so basically FIFA!
Premiership – 12 foreign owners (including Lebron James at Liverpool apparently)
Championship -15 foreign owners
The season is set for an interesting beginning, minus Spurs and Everton which is postponed due to the recent riots. But the show must go on and the Premiership is back and booming; despite foreign owners, rising ticket prices, rubbish kick off times, overpaid players who cheat on their gorgeous other halves and the return of Delia “letsbyhavingyou’ Smith its still the premiership and we bloody love it…what a bunch of suckers we all are.
“They need to strengthen in the window” ; The Curse of the Parasitic Cliché
Listening to the radio the other day I took objection to the comments of the expert “analyst” or so they are called…basically the guy who is in to support the commentator by chipping in every 5 minutes or so. This is how the dialogue went;
“What do you think about Tottenham this season? Have they got enough to maintain a title challenge or do they need to strengthen in the window” asked the commentator
“I think Tottenham have a good team and could challenge for the top 2 positions in the league. If they could just add 2 or 3 players in the transfer window they would go close” stated the analyst competently.
“Interesting, where do you think they need to strengthen? What sort of player do they need? ” Replied the commentator amiably.
Cue completely flustered man desperately trying to bullshit his way out of the corner he put himself in. ”Well um, um they definitely need a striker, probably a midfielder and another defender” He didn’t know because his response was a token and standard response to the question posed, “do you think Tottenham need to strengthen in January?” I mean honestly this is an “expert” talking and what he serves up is another example of the parasitic cliche; The parasitic cliche lives inside a lot of pundits and feeds of the non specific, repetitive and mundane feedback we hear on a weekly basis… and just when you think they can’t get lack any more incision and acuity out comes the cliche, evident in this case by the old “they need to strengthen in the window” line. the analyst said they needed to strengthen because he felt it was the right thing to say, he didn’t really believe it or for that matter seem to really know whether they did or they didn’t.
It is true Tottenham have had an excellent season; they are exciting to watch, play with purpose, drive and pace that gets all football fans out of their seats. ”I’d pay to watch Tottenham play” quoted David Moyes in the build up to their premier league game this week. However their success has stemmed in my opinion from several things. Firstly they have a good blend of youth and experience with an average age of their starting squad being 27 – One of the higher in the league, the players could be considered to be in their prime. Certainly this seems true of Bale, Modric, Parker and several of the back 4. They have used only 20 players (from starting) this season – the fewest in the premier league, indicating they have, by and large, kept key squad members fit and have been able to play something like their strongest team on a regular basis. Couple an exciting and talented squad with limited injuries (I know all teams get injuries but star players like Bale have been largely injury free) and a manager willing to ‘have-a-go’ then you have a chance to be consistent and that is what Tottenham have done this season and what is pushing them up the pecking order – consistency.
Consistency comes from playing a similar team each week, the ability to remain constant and therefore replicate successful techniques and responses in new situations and different scenarios. The players in turn gain confidence and motivation from this success, want and are able to to replicate it more frequently and therefore carry their confidence into their next performance. My point is that the last thing you need is a £25 million player turning up on your doorstep with a forehead tattoo saying “the gaffa has to play his new signing”. Similarly the thought of adding 2 or 3 players to an already tight unit half way through the season runs the risk of doing more harm than good; unsettling players, hampering the confidence of players and deflating a group, high on their own success thus far. It is my contention that the window is far more profitable for teams who need an impact or a boost, a team for example who might be hovering around relegation, as opposed to a top four side who are looking to strengthen for maybe the title run in or a push for Europe.
Needless to say if the switch is made a reality, the player in question can often feel an even weightier expectation, especially if a large price tag carries them aloft into their new club amidst cries of him becoming the new club’s newest legend or indeed saviour. You only have to look at the biggest exponent of the January flop; Fernando Torres. The weight of the price tag seems to have pushed his already out of sorts form into further disarray. I saw him play for Liverpool in the flesh and he was awesome, an admirable specimen who was stockier and more powerful than I expected and had the movement to disorientate the best defenders in the world, ask Nemanja Vidic. However his arrival at Chelsea for whatever reason has not worked. But he isn’t alone, strikers with big price tags are a big no no in the January ‘sales’.
A book I can highly recommend – Moneyball, is a fantastically astute look into the statistics associated with baseball and their implementation during the draft selection process that exists in US sport. There are several players that, statistically, you should never invest your money in e.g. High School Pitchers who’s record, statistically is far worse than College pitchers. However the word of mouth and subjective approach from scouts ensured that High School pitchers are often more fashionable for the ‘potential’ they possess. Billy Beane (head coach of the Oakland A’s) would argue that he would prefer someone with proven form at a higher level (i.e. a college pitcher). He would cheer every time a high school pitcher was drafted leaving his 1st choice draft picks (usually college players) left to be swept up by him and his statistical outlook. In January, strikers are often bought for overinflated prices and brought in as ‘the answer’. However I suspect there is someone out there cheering as loud as Billy Beane every time Roman Abramovich opens his Torres directed , new year chequebook.
I’m sure that same person could be heard laughing when;
- Middlesborough signed Alfonso Alves for nearly £13 million in 2008. His 10 goals in 48 appearances ensured Middlesborough were rightly relegated for their rashness and condemned Alves to a life of huge wages and cuban cigars in Qatari football. At least someone benefitted!?
- Jose Antonio Reyes singed for £10 million by Arsenal. Reyes was brought up in a caravan, dribbling around garden gnomes to learn his trade. When he got his big move to England’s capital he was more concerned about a severe lack of understanding of English than producing on the pitch. He found the words “score” and “goals” particularly difficult to comprehend.
- Andy Carroll took the total of overpriced strikers moving last January to £85 million pounds. In fairness it is probable a lot of pressure to think that despite your poor attitude off the field, anti social behaviour orders, burnt out cars and social and domestic issues you are valued at the same price as clean water for an African shanty town for the rest of their life. To be fair he does remind me of a camel, maybe he would be of use in Africa after all. £35 million is an investment Liverpool are still waiting on a return for.
- Georgios Samaras broke all of Manchester City supporters hearts by signing for them for £6 million in 2006. His 8 goals in 53 matches screams SPL and thats where he ended up.
- Real Madrid goal machine Fernando Morientes pitched up at Anfield in 2005 to deposit 8 goals in 41 games at a return of just under £1 million per goal.
- Supersub and everyones favourite “did he really play for England” Michael Rickets and his £3.5 million move to Middlesborough. Predictably 3 goals in 32 games saw him narrowly miss out on Euro 2004.
- Gianfranco Zola stumped up £9 million on Savio Nsreko. Cue some very unhappy hammers as brescia’s loss was West Ham’s well loss as well. 10 games 0 goals and swift return flight to Florence to ply his trade in Seria B.
In fairness it isn’t just strikers, disasters such as Jean Alain Boumsong further epitomise the panic buying nature of January. £8 million for a defender proven…in the SPL. Who would have thought Graeme Souness, now an expert analyst on Sky Sports, would have the tactical nous and guile to pair him up with Titus Bramble…I can hear Billy Beane now, laughing his socks off.
Ultimately it is clearly a time of caution but there have been some real success stories of the January transfer window since its introduction;
- Henrik Larson’s move to Man Utd was just the ignition Fergie needed in his squad and the Swede helped United achieve another premier league title.
- Christophe Duggarry gave Birmingham City a huge lift in 2003 and his 5 goals were memorable in keeping them in the premier league.
- Mikael Arteta, Ashley Young and Javier Masherano are other examples of players signed to have a big impact on clubs that aren’t quite at their peak. You only have to look at the signing of Daniel Sturridge for Bolton last season, his goals were season defining and how they have missed him this year. Sturridge along with Larson and Dugarry are illustrations of how January can be of use. An inspiration not a flagship. Mascherano, Arteta and Young portray a more circumspect approach of signing talented young players with huge potential for relatively little money compared to Torres and Carroll and allowing them time to blood in without the media hype of the ‘the £30 million saviour’ arriving. It is in my opinion these type of players that is what the January window is used for, however every year some managers never learn.
Last January there was £225 million spent in the window on ‘squad strengthening’!! And in my opinion for every Dugarry there seems to be a plethora of Torres’. I will always allow myself a rye chuckle when the cash is splashed in large sums by clubs in January, even if football’s expert analyst and his parasitic cliche feels they definitely needed to ‘strengthen their squad in the window‘.
Gary Speed; Prince of Wales…King of Hearts.
Someone who is not that in tune with football asked me today, not in a nasty way, why this player Gary Speed was getting so much media exposure? There was no malice in the question and she indeed commented on how extremely sad the situation was however my response was immediate and unequivocal; ‘he was just one of those players who ways a bit of a legend, the sort of player most fans and managers would have happily had in their team’. He wasn’t a Rooney or a Gazza but there wouldn’t be many managers who would have swapped him.
677 appearances, 103 goals for his 5 clubs to accompany his 85 National caps and 7 Welsh goals. An MBE to match a glowing start in management for his beloved national team. Enviably good looking, revered as a legend by all who knew him and those that didn’t. I have never once cheered his name for club or country but when his name rang out at Swansea on Sunday there was a lump in my throat. Read More…
Sports Leviathan’s Football Bucket List
Episode 6 of the Sports Leviathan ‘things to do in football before you die’ is up on the Headers and Volleys website. Click the link to read the first 6 entries
Read Sports Leviathan’s assessment on Flat racing’s final hurrah on both sides of the pond
Firstly, another plug for the continuing ‘Bucket list’ series on the Headers and Volleys website written by sports leviathan Click here to continue reading entries 4 and 5.
Today at Doncaster sees the November Handicap finish off the flat season in Britain. Firstly a big congrtulations to Paul Hannagan who will retain his title of champion Jock unless Silvestre De Sousa pulls a miracle 4 timer out the bag to force a tie. Hannagan has had over 1100 rides this year and is an illustration of what you can achieve with hard work and tenacity in your profession. The November handicap itself in my opinion looks set up for Pekan Star. Roger Varian (an SL favourite) has kept Pekan Star in training despite a few sub standard runs. He has been gelded, is unexposed anf will relish the ground at 12-1 he looks a good price even if the price does reflect his recent average form.
Elsewhere it is interesting to see Kauto Star’s half brother Kauto Stone take his chance at Down Royal, a well trodden path for the Kauto-Nicholls connections. There will be many eager eyes on him. If Nicholls feels he is up to this task then he may well claim this prize for a second year in a row.
In America the Breeders cup is often a place to get good prices on European horses , however I am not sure the raiding party are quite as strong this year. IT will be amazing to see Goldikova win her 4th Mares Turf and in so doing cement her already sure place in World racing’s hall of fame. However it is another French horse which really takes my fancy. Brigantin, in the Marathon, has had some very admirable results this year, none least finishing 3rd in the Ascot Gold Cup. He has also gone on to defeat Dunaden the subsequent Melbourne cup winner. The French satying division is very strong at the moment, the horse is bred from America anyway and given he has run as far as 2m 4f I suspect the heavy conditions over at Churchill downs will play into his hands, so he is my nap of the day.
Advice -
3 pts. Brigantin – 5.20 Churchill Downs Win @ 7/1 Ladbrokes
1 pt Pekan Star – 3.10 Doncaster E/W @ 12/1 Hills
.5 pt Trixie Trixie Brigantin, Pekan Star and Kauto Stone
Bucket list entries 2 & 3 up on Headers and Volleys
As I expand my entries on my own bucket list – Things to do in football before you die, let me know what entries you would like on yours. Click on the link and join the debate.




